What's The Difference Between Detonation And Pre-ignition?

Suranto W/Shutterstock

Like overmuch successful life, nan quality betwixt detonation and pre-ignition, and their effects, comes down to timing. Both mention to a business erstwhile an engine's fuel/air substance combusts astatine nan incorrect time, but detonation occurs aft nan spark plug sparks and pre-ignition — unsurprisingly — occurs beforehand.

Of course, it's bully to beryllium connected nan aforesaid page erstwhile discussing motor cycles, truthful here's a speedy refresher connected really a emblematic internal-combustion motor works: The first "stroke" of these four-stroke engines is intake, which refers to erstwhile a piston moves down successful a cylinder to make room for substance and air. The piston goes up to compress nan substance during nan 2nd stroke, and nan spark goes disconnected erstwhile nan piston reaches nan top, causing nan 3rd stroke, combustion. Finally, nan piston moves upward again to expel leftover gases into nan exhaust system.

An motor experiences pre-ignition if there's different high-enough root of power successful nan cylinder to origin nan substance and aerial to commencement burning earlier nan spark goes off. At that point, nan piston is moving upward, trying to compress nan fuel/air substance against its earthy resistance, and it ends up getting deed by nan downward-expanding shockwaves of early combustion. Just astir immoderate irregularity successful nan cylinder, from c buildups to a bad valve, tin origin nan problem by heating up to utmost temperatures. Coincidentally, though, it's akin to the subject down diesel engines, which trust connected glow plugs alternatively of spark plugs.

Petr Smagin/Getty Images

Beyond nan timing portion of nan equation, detonation is reasonably akin to pre-ignition successful really it operates: Again, location are basking spots successful nan cylinder, and they tin origin nan substance and aerial to combust erstwhile it shouldn't.

A cardinal quality is that nan basking spots successful detonation are heated up molecules of nan fuel/air substance itself that person been near complete aft astir of nan combustion has already happened. Here, though, a chemic alteration from nan power leaves nan remaining molecules extra-sensitive to pressure, and they ignite from nan squeezing force. In addition, location isn't astir arsenic overmuch worldly remaining to ignite astatine nan incorrect time, letting an motor withstand much successful nan measurement of detonation than pre-ignition. Backed by a afloat complaint of substance and air, connected nan different hand, pre-ignition causes truthful overmuch power and unit that it tin destruct a piston caput successful conscionable a fewer hundredths of a second.

That's not to opportunity you should fto your motor spell if you announcement it knocking — a communal denotation of detonation. The sound is nan sound of shockwaves bouncing disconnected nan cylinder walls, and they're truthful beardown they tin destruct nan accustomed bladed obstruction of lubrication betwixt nan walls and nan piston heads, starring to highly destructive metal-on-metal friction. Left agelong enough, it tin destruct nan motor conscionable arsenic surely arsenic pre-ignition — and don't hide that rising prices mean your adjacent repair measure whitethorn beryllium a batch much expensive that you thought.

Mykola Pokhodzhay/Getty Images

It turns retired that definite engines — turbocharged units pinch nonstop injection — tin beryllium particularly prone to what's called low-speed pre-ignition. The results are nan same, successful that nan fuel-air substance combusts earlier nan spark plug goes off, but nan low-speed pre-ignition occurs during, well, debased speeds, pinch nan motor turning astatine a debased number of rpm earlier a abrupt request for powerfulness — for illustration erstwhile you're taking disconnected from a dormant stop.

Experts constituent to 2 apt culprits here: First, it could beryllium excess c deposits that clasp capable power from nan erstwhile combustion changeable to ignite nan fuel/air substance earlier nan adjacent 1 is expected to begin. Others opportunity lipid gets past nan piston rings and into nan combustion enclosure of nan cylinder, mixing pinch substance to shape comparatively ample droplets that, successful turn, tin spontaneously combust nether unit — earlier nan spark plug fires. For much connected really spark plugs activity and why they matter, cheque retired our guide to different spark plug types.

The bully news is that, complete nan years, automakers person worked to thief destruct nan problem done engineering changes to engines themselves, specified arsenic modifying piston heads, and fine-tuning nan package that oversees spark timing. In addition, erstwhile it was discovered that definite detergents successful lipid could summation nan chance of low-speed pre-ignition, and definite additives could trim it, nan American Petroleum Institute designated a caller people of oils, SN Plus, that were specifically safe for usage successful turbocharged engines pinch nonstop injection.