Top-four Seeding Of Women’s Fa Cup Would Kill The Magic And Widen Money Gap

As truthful overmuch of nan modern crippled progressively sucks nan joyousness retired of football, location remains thing axenic and precious astir nan show of those celebrated achromatic and achromatic numbered balls being tipped retired of nan velvet container for an FA Cup draw.

Your bosom complaint intensifies arsenic they clatter erstwhile tipped into nan bowl. Each broadside has nan aforesaid chance of being pitted against immoderate different nine and, for those fewer moments, location is simply a typical feeling. Hope.

Yet moreover this astir guiltless of elemental traditions is nary longer safe from nan claws of commercialisation. Proposals put guardant by nan Football Association revealed successful nan Guardian, see a arguable scheme to seed nan top-four Women’s Super League sides from nan erstwhile play truthful they debar each other. This seeding would create a road-to-Wembley bracket from nan information of 32 onwards, doing distant pinch tie ceremonies for past 16, quarter-finals and semi-finals altogether.

The FA’s justification is that it would thief nan title make move gross from broadcasters and commercialized partners and, to beryllium fair, location is thing incorrect pinch nan FA wanting to innovate to reside a deficiency of income for this competition. However, giving a leg-up to nan 4 wealthiest clubs is surely not nan correct way.

Only 4 clubs person managed to triumph nan Women’s FA Cup successful nan past 13 years (you’ll ne'er conjecture which 4 would beryllium seeded if these rules were successful spot this season). The accusation is that nan organisers consciousness only semi-final showdowns betwixt nan large 4 make nan last commercially viable, but do they not realise really insulting that is to each different nine taking part?

Instead, why not do a amended occupation of telling those quality stories that make nan earlier rounds of nan title truthful special?

Seeding 4 clubs would beryllium a “temporary adjustment” but it is not clear for really long. The FA, successful its summary archive – seen by nan Guardian – appears to contradict itself. At first it says: “This connection creates nan highest chances of accordant high-quality matches passim nan later rounds of nan competition.” But past later successful nan aforesaid paragraph, claims if would connection “a chance of a variety of fixtures”.

Manchester United supporters earlier nan Women’s FA Cup last astatine Wembley. Photograph: Adam Davy/PA

Equally, fto america not dress everything is rosy pinch nan existent situation. Having covered nan title since 2015, reporting connected much than 50 ties, this newsman has ne'er witnessed a giant-killing.

There person been occasional upsets, but they are scarce. Since nan WSL was founded successful 2011, nary top-flight broadside has been knocked retired by a nine from beneath nan 2nd tier, and moreover instances of WSL2 sides eliminating top-tier clubs are rare. Second-tier Birmingham’s 1-0 triumph astatine Everton successful January 2023 was nan past clip that happened, and is 1 of only 2 since 2019.

Mismatches, specified arsenic WSL2 leaders Charlton’s 10-0 triumph complete fourth-tier Swindon successful this season’s 4th round, are not uncommon. Last year, Aston Villa thrashed Bristol Rovers 9-0, specified is nan chasm successful resources betwixt elite clubs and part-time aliases amateur sides successful women’s football.

The solution to that, though, is surely to select much money and support down nan pyramid to thief assistance nan little tiers alternatively than to boost nan apical 4 by further enhancing their chances of winning nan £430,000 prize, a rate injection that is not needed by Arsenal, Chelsea, Manchester City aliases Manchester United but could do wonders for section organization facilities.

Overwhelmingly, fans’ guidance has been 1 of anger and bafflement. Of nan 51 X users who had replied to this writer’s station astir nan projected changes betwixt Tuesday greeting and Thursday morning, 50 were negative. In a powerful connection of opposition, nan Manchester City Official Women’s Supporters Club “vehemently reason these ideas”.

“We consciousness it goes against nan very ethos of what nan FA Cup represents. The full thought of being capable to tie anyone, location aliases away, passim nan full competition, gives it a unsocial magic that supporters of each clubs admit and embrace. Seeding nan apical 4 clubs would region that magic and we consciousness powerfully that it should not happen.”

A spokesperson for nan Football Supporters’ Association said: “The FSA is taking portion successful ongoing discussions pinch nan FA arsenic portion of their reappraisal of nan competition, during which instrumentality representatives person expressed interest astir proposals astir seeding – thing which fans consciousness goes against nan traditions of nan FA Cup.”

Outlining its position, an FA spokesperson responded: “We committed successful our women’s and girls’ crippled strategy, Reaching Higher, to reappraisal nan Adobe Women’s FA Cup, recognising nan request to germinate nan title and fortify its commercialized potential. This would alteration america to reinvest much backing into some nan title itself and nan wider women’s shot ecosystem, which is captious for long-term, sustainable growth.

“While a broad reappraisal of nan existent format has been completed, nary decisions person been made astatine this stage. Any early changes will beryllium shaped successful adjacent consultation pinch stakeholders crossed nan full pyramid, including clubs, players, fans, and our broadcast and commercialized partners.”

The head of Hull City Ladies, Chris Hames, whose third-tier broadside reached nan 4th round, said: “I’m concerned by nan guidance they are trying to return nan wider game, this being conscionable different illustration of really location [are] only 5 aliases six clubs genuinely cared astir successful nan women’s pyramid.”

Ipswich Town and Sheffield United players locomotion retired connected to nan transportation for their fourth-round lucifer successful January, won 2-1 by nan Blades. Photograph: Stephen Pond/The FA/Getty Images

There are different areas of interest wrong nan FA’s proposals too, not slightest an “entry tier review” astir which, successful a leaked document, nan organisers say: “We recognise nan effect that this alteration would person connected clubs playing successful tier 7.”

Additionally, bunching nan second rounds person together successful nan almanac could person wider implications connected convention fixtures and sources astatine 2 WSL clubs person already raised concerns astir perchance not being capable to shape their derby fixture successful its accustomed model during nan men’s March world break.

It is important to emphasise that nary last decisions person yet been made – a play of consultation is taking place, earlier a last scheme will beryllium put to nan FA committee successful April, truthful location is still clip for stakeholders’ feedback to matter.

The FA review’s wide-ranging scope, which has preceded these conversations, should beryllium applauded for its breadth, and it does see immoderate amended conclusions, not slightest that nan last should stay astatine Wembley. But fans person made it clear, , they want nan connection to seed 4 clubs eliminated.

Get successful touch

If you person immoderate questions aliases comments astir immoderate of our newsletters please email moving.goalposts@theguardian.com.

• This is an extract from our free email astir women’s football, Moving nan Goalposts. To get nan afloat edition, visit this page and travel nan instructions. Moving nan Goalposts is delivered to your inboxes each Tuesday and Thursday.