This Tax Dispute Could Cost Arizonans Their Rockauto Access

Unai Huizi Photography/Shutterstock

RockAuto isn't nan only spot you tin find car parts online, but it's surely 1 of nan biggest. But if you unrecorded successful Arizona, you astir apt won't beryllium capable to shop location aft November, moreover if you really want a circumstantial part. Why? Because nan Joe Arpaio State precocious decided nan parts tract owes astir $11 cardinal successful unpaid income taxes, an magnitude RockAuto's president said successful a caller op-ed amounts to "far much money than we earned successful 20 years trading car parts to Arizonans." What nan heck? That doesn't sound right. 

Well, arsenic it turns out, it's a small complicated, but it boils down to nan authorities deciding that RockAuto has a beingness beingness successful nan authorities and truthful owes backmost taxes connected its sales, positive penalties. RockAuto disagrees and has said it will simply extremity doing business successful Arizona adjacent period arsenic it tries to activity retired a solution pinch nan state. Unfortunately for astir of us, knowing nan specifications of what's going connected besides requires moving our measurement done respective tribunal cases. The bully news is, The Autopian precocious published a heavy dive into this full situation, and while it's long, likelihood are, it'll reply immoderate questions you whitethorn have. 

Until very recently, states weren't allowed to cod income taxes from online retailers that didn't person a beingness beingness successful those states. However, successful 2018, nan Supreme Court decided that, actually, states could cod taxes from companies that do business successful nan state, moreover without establishing a beingness beingness there. That, of course, made nan states happy, since states emotion being allowed to cod much taxes. Arizona responded pinch the Transaction Privilege Tax, which went into effect successful 2019, and RockAuto has been collecting and paying income taxes from its Arizona income ever since. 

RockAuto and different online retailers whitethorn not person been thrilled astir that ruling, but they complied. It was only erstwhile the Arizona Department of Revenue conducted an audit that things sewage contentious.

Kelvn/Getty Images

Following its audit, ADOR decided that, actually, RockAuto really did person a beingness beingness successful nan authorities and truthful owed backmost taxes and penalties. $11 cardinal worthy of backmost taxes and penalties. RockAuto disagreed, arguing that utilizing suppliers that whitethorn beryllium physically based successful Arizona doesn't magnitude to RockAuto itself having a beingness beingness successful nan state. The Superior Court of nan State of Arizona sided pinch RockAuto. As The Autopian put it:

However, nan Court claimed that RockAuto's suppliers successful Arizona do not beryllium to thief RockAuto found a marketplace successful Arizona, arsenic ADOR insisted. Instead, nan Court claimed, whether a customer gets a portion from a supplier successful Arizona aliases not is wholly up to them. RockAuto tin beryllium configured to get parts to you based connected your desired cost, speed, aliases efficiency. Because of this, only 11 percent of orders placed successful Arizona are fulfilled by suppliers successful Arizona, and nan Arizona suppliers vessel astir packages to different states.

The Court ruled that RockAuto did not person nan requisite beingness beingness for nan authorities to effort to cod taxes from RockAuto. The Court past ordered ADOR to salary RockAuto $892.95 successful costs and $136,875 successful lawyer fees.

Instead of letting that beryllium nan extremity of it, ADOR appealed, and that time, it won:

In nan end, nan Arizona Court of Appeals ruled that RockAuto does person a beingness successful Arizona, since it has its Arizona suppliers vessel to Arizona customers, usage RockAuto's systems, and grip RockAuto's returns. The Court supports its conclusion by pointing retired that RockAuto's labor besides visited nan suppliers successful Arizona and that RockAuto sends promotional materials to customers successful nan state. The Arizona Court of Appeals ruling besides seems to connote that nan Arizona Tax Court mightiness person been applying Quill's nexus trial successful a post-Quill world. Either way, this spells bad news for RockAuto.

As you tin imagine, RockAuto wasn't happy astir that decision. As president Jim Taylor put it successful nan antecedently mentioned 2024 Arizona Capitol Times op-ed:

Somehow, each Arizona mill and wholesaler trading parts to america became our branch agency erstwhile we asked them to vessel straight to our customers. Address labels became stores, refrigerator magnets became salespeople and, magically, RockAuto was successful Arizona.

No erstwhile tribunal lawsuit (including ours successful nan Arizona Tax Court) recovered a retailer "physically present" without labor aliases assets aliases personification making in-state interaction pinch customers. ADoR's ain publications opportunity "drop-shipping" from Arizona suppliers does not create taxation liability. But ADoR persists successful demanding six years of taxes (which we didn't cod from customers) positive liking and penalties — acold much money than we earned successful 20 years trading car parts to Arizonans!

At nan time, Taylor said RockAuto whitethorn person to extremity doing business successful Arizona, but he didn't see a circumstantial deadline. However, a TikTok (embedded above) claiming RockAuto will nary longer vessel orders to Arizona has precocious gone viral. So is that it? Can Arizona residents nary longer bid from RockAuto? Not exactly, but erstwhile The Autopian reached retired to Taylor for clarification, he explained successful an email that "the existent business is not sustainable truthful we scheme to extremity income to Arizona successful early November." So if you request car parts, you amended get your bid successful fast. 

That said, Taylor's consequence was astatine slightest 7 paragraphs agelong and included a batch much specifications that it would beryllium adjacent to see here, truthful why don't you head connected complete to The Autopian to springiness nan full point a read. And while you're there, possibly show Mercedes her aged Jalop-buddies opportunity hi.