The 6 Car Insurance Companies Customers Leave The Most, According To Consumer Reports

Sinenkiy/Getty Images

Are you a switcher? More and much drivers are shopping astir and switching their car security companies erstwhile they find a amended deal. Consumer Reports surveyed 40,000 policyholders past twelvemonth and recovered that 30% had switched carriers sometime successful nan past 5 years. JD Power reported that well over half of policyholders successful 2024 shopped around. (In fact, many group are cutting aliases moreover dropping their car insurance — though you shouldn't do that — to prevention money.) According to Consumer Reports, group often prevention importantly erstwhile they do switch.

What's surprising, though, is which companies consumers are switching distant from. The companies pinch nan worst switching ratios (percentage of customers switching to/percentage of customers switching away), according to Consumer Reports, are Liberty Mutual (43%/57%), Hanover (41%/59%), Geico (40%/60%), Kemper (35%/65%), Farmers (34%/66%), and Nationwide (28%/72%). One would deliberation from really good known astir of those names are that they wouldn't beryllium hemorrhaging clients.

Consumer Reports has agelong recommended shopping astir security rates each twelvemonth aliases two. That proposal surely makes consciousness from a financial standpoint. It's nary coincidence nan companies pinch nan worst switching ratios are often more costly compared to different carriers, particularly nan ones pinch nan champion switching ratios. A batch of group don't recognize that shopping astir could prevention them money, moreover aft an accident, speeding ticket, aliases DUI. At nan very least, it's worthy a fewer telephone calls aliases checking online.

Phiwath Jittamas/Getty Images

It's ne'er bully erstwhile much of a company's customers move distant than motion up. That's nan lawsuit pinch each of nan companies connected our list, though Liberty Mutual isn't nan worst exammple. Still, 43% of Liberty Mutual customers who made a alteration during those 5 years switched to them, arsenic opposed to nan 57% who switched away.

Why person nan customers switched away? There tin beryllium a number of reasons, though Consumer Reports makes nan constituent that two-thirds of nan 40,000 customers it surveyed (not conscionable Liberty Mutual customers) switched distant from their erstwhile carriers for cost-related reasons. Liberty Mutual's rates are successful statement pinch that reasoning. The institution connected average, charges drivers successful their 30s $2,686 per twelvemonth for afloat coverage, which is $400 supra nan nationalist average, and $1,100 higher than State Farm, a ample nationwide competitor. Liberty Mutual raised its rates by 31.1% betwixt 2022 and 2023, correct successful nan mediate of nan clip play specified successful nan survey. 

Might location beryllium different reasons customers person switched away? According to nan National Association of Insurance Commissioners, astir complaints revenge pinch authorities agencies astir Liberty Mutual had to do pinch declare handling, including delays and adjuster handling. We expected much from you, LIMU Emu.

Phiwath Jittamas/Getty Images

Geico is benignant of a astonishment introduction connected this list, and not because of really tiny that small gecko is. The company's rates are little than astir of its competitors and mostly little than nan nationalist average, particularly erstwhile it comes to minimum (liability-only) coverage. Teen drivers, for instance, are charged connected mean conscionable $152 per period for liability, arsenic opposed to nan nationalist mean of $190.

Geico seems to beryllium 1 of nan much forgiving security companies, too, pinch lower-than-average liability rates for drivers pinch a DUI, a speeding ticket, aliases an at-fault accident. It besides offers important discounts for things for illustration airbags and having an anti-theft system, though successful 2024, it notified respective customers that it would not renew nan policies connected their Cybertrucks.

Yet for immoderate reason, Geico's switching to/switching distant ratio, 40% to 60%, was moreover worse than Liberty Mutual's. Why mightiness customers beryllium switching away? Well, moreover though it has immoderate of nan lowest rates, it did raise its rates betwixt 2022 and 2023 by 29.1%. Customers person a inclination to move erstwhile that happens, moreover erstwhile those rates are still little than nan nationalist average. 

A commenter at Insurify, Brian, said Geico raised his rates by $145 a period only 5 months aft he signed up for a policy, prompting him to switch. Another commenter, Audrey, said she had been pinch Geico for complete 10 years, yet has decided it's clip for a change, since nan carrier's rates "keep going higher and higher".

Kak Iki/Getty Images

For each customer who has switched to Farmers successful nan past 5 years, astir 2 person switched away. It has nan second-worst switching ratio connected nan list, pinch 34% of Farmers customers successful nan study having switched to nan institution successful nan past 5 years, and 66% having switched away. In different words, it's been bleeding customers.

It's not difficult to ideate why drivers person been fleeing this company, fixed its pricing. On average, Farmers charges a 35-year-old driver pinch a cleanable driving grounds complete $4,000 a twelvemonth for full-coverage. That's astir doubly arsenic overmuch arsenic respective different awesome insurers. The institution charges connected mean $102 per period aliases $1,218 per twelvemonth for liability only. Compare that to a nationalist mean of $626 per year. And cheque your in installments people earlier signing up; mediocre in installments will get you an yearly premium of $7,523 for afloat sum connected average.

High prices whitethorn not beryllium nan only logic group person been switching distant from this carrier. Farmers made Consumer Reports' 2024 lowest-rated car security list, arsenic did each of nan different awesome carriers we database present isolated from for Nationwide. It scored debased successful wide customer satisfaction, coverage, thief and advice, argumentation review, and service. According to nan National Association of Insurance Commissioners, astir complaints revenge pinch authorities agencies against Farmers person had to do pinch policyholder work and declare handling, but "premium & rating" and "premium notice/billing" were besides precocious connected nan list.

Perawit Boonchu/Getty Images

Nationwide's switching ratio is truthful bad (28% switched to/72% switched away), it's a wonderment nan institution manages to enactment successful business. Its marketplace stock has surely slipped successful nan past respective years. In 2009, it was successful sixth place, dropping to eighth spot by 2018, past retired of nan apical 10 altogether by 2024.

Predictably, it's 1 of nan much costly security carriers, though not arsenic costly arsenic Farmers. Full sum costs an mean of $233 per period aliases $2,794 per year, compared to nan nationalist mean of $194 per month, aliases $2,324 per year. That $2,794 per twelvemonth is besides nan mean Nationwide will complaint a 35-year-old driver pinch a cleanable driving record, respective 100 dollars much than Geico, Progressive, and State Farm and complete $1,000 much than Travelers. 

Like Farmers, Nationwide is not benignant to those pinch mediocre credit, charging those customers $4,192 per year. It's not incredibly forgiving, either. One speeding summons will get you an yearly premium of $3,803 for afloat coverage; it's $4,525 for drivers who person been successful an at-fault crash, and $5,948 for a DUI. If you've had immoderate of those, Nationwide is not connected your side.

We should constituent retired that Nationwide does person respective discounts and absorbing extras. For example, it offers a discount for students betwixt 16 and 24 who support astatine slightest a B average. It besides offers a vanishing deductible, taking disconnected $100 for each accident-free year, up to $500.

Mehaniq/Shutterstock

We separated The Hanover and Kemper from nan remainder of nan list, arsenic they are location companies, not disposable nationwide. You tin often find bully deals pinch a location company, but not truthful overmuch pinch these two. 

The Hanover sells policies successful conscionable 19 states, and it's connected par pinch Farmers arsenic acold arsenic value goes, charging connected mean $334 per period aliases $4,012 per twelvemonth for afloat coverage. Liability costs $123 per period aliases $1,471 per year, overmuch higher than nan nationalist mean of $626. Drivers pinch mediocre in installments should conscionable shop location else, arsenic they could find themselves charged upward of $14,466 per year, aliases $1,206 per month.

Kemper is disposable successful almost 40 states, but it is still considered a location carrier. It's besides considered nonstandard, successful that it specializes successful drivers who mightiness person problem getting sum anyplace else, possibly owed to a DUI aliases having fto their argumentation lapse. Kemper's rates aren't highly high, but a small higher than average: $206 per period aliases $2,467 per twelvemonth for afloat sum and $87 per period aliases $1,044 per twelvemonth for minimum coverage, connected average. Kemper is astir apt a bully "starter carrier" for drivers pinch blemished driving records aliases in installments histories, explaining nan company's precocious turnover of customers.

We should statement that your individual experiences pinch each of these companies mightiness beryllium different, arsenic rates are based connected a batch of different factors. But it's still a bully thought to shop around.