Tesla Vet Says That ‘reviewing Real Products’ — Not Mockups — Is The Key To Staying Innovative

Trending 14 hours ago

GM’s EVs person been connected a rotation lately. After trading conscionable nan Chevy Bolt for years, a activity of caller models — now up to 17 afloat electrified vehicles — has pushed nan automaker into 2nd spot successful nan U.S. down Tesla. 

How did it get there? With a small thief from a Tesla veteran.

GM committee personnel Jon McNeil was president of Tesla during nan improvement and preamble of nan Model 3, a important play of nan company’s growth. One of nan things he credits for Tesla’s occurrence is really Elon Musk ran merchandise meetings. 

“No slides was our first rule,” McNeil told nan assemblage earlier this period astatine TC All Stage successful Boston. “You person to beryllium reviewing existent product.”

Every week, elder activity would beryllium down pinch merchandise leaders to reappraisal their progress. The believe was inspired by an brushwood Musk had pinch Steve Jobs, McNeil said. 

“There was this belief that I deliberation is true: Steve Jobs didn’t person a ton of clip aliases patience for Elon successful nan early days. And early successful nan early days, Elon would effort to pursuit Steve down astatine events and parties successful Silicon Valley for advice. And Steve didn’t for illustration Elon, and truthful would often move his backmost to him erstwhile he approached him. 

“But 1 night, Elon sewage fortunate and said, ‘Steve, if you had 1 portion of proposal for maine arsenic a young entrepreneur’ — he had conscionable just done PayPal and was joining nan squad astatine Tesla — ‘what would that be?’ Steve said, ‘Elon, you’re now successful nan hardware business, but nan hardware business is simply a batch for illustration nan package business. If you want to beryllium successful successful business, you person to get 1 point right, and that is, you person to person a cleanable product. And if nan merchandise is beautiful, it will waste itself.”

Techcrunch event

San Francisco | October 27-29, 2025

Musk took that to heart, McNeil said, and nan conception of a cleanable merchandise became cardinal to merchandise improvement astatine Tesla.

“The point we were looking for first of each was astonishment and delight. Like, are we doing thing that is going to conscionable make personification spell wow aliases laughter aliases person fun? 

“Crazy illustration of that is nan fart button,” McNeil said, referring to a package fastener branded “Emissions Testing Mode” that would simulate flatulence done nan car’s speakers. 

The institution besides prized minimalism, which connected nan package broadside meant keeping functions accessible successful less than 2 taps connected nan screen. 

“It has to beryllium a benignant of a nary brainer for nan mean user. Then we would double backmost nan designer — nan lead designer was ever successful nan room — and past we would say, OK, Franz, now make it beautiful.”

Meetings for illustration those, wherever nan existent merchandise was reviewed, not a mockup, helped sphere Tesla’s civilization arsenic it grew, McNeil said. “You tin ideate nan civilization that gets communicated erstwhile group are bringing their A crippled to nan CEO each week. Because you’re not going to bring your B crippled to nan CEO — particularly that CEO, because he’s going to occurrence you,” he said.

“That keeps that institution connected a one-week cadence of innovation. Every week they’re making advancement because of nan merchandise reviews.”

McNeil near Tesla successful early 2018. In 2022, he was added to nan committee astatine GM. 

“One of nan things I’m astir proud of is Mary Barra, CEO, and Mark Reuss, president, [who oversee] a 275,000 person, $200 cardinal gross company, are moving merchandise reviews each week wherever there’s nary slides. You’ve sewage to spot nan existent merchandise [whether it’s] hardware, software. If it’s hardware, it’s successful nan room. You’re rubbing it. You’re emotion it,” he said.

“That worldly is truthful powerful. And it’s led to GMs preamble of 17 EVs, now nan 2nd champion trading EVs successful nan country. Because they’re conscionable connected product, each week.”

Tim De Chant is simply a elder ambiance newsman astatine TechCrunch. He has written for a wide scope of publications, including Wired magazine, nan Chicago Tribune, Ars Technica, The Wire China, and NOVA Next, wherever he was founding editor. De Chant is besides a teacher successful MIT’s Graduate Program successful Science Writing, and he was awarded a Knight Science Journalism Fellowship astatine MIT successful 2018, during which clip he studied ambiance technologies and explored caller business models for journalism. He received his PhD successful biology science, policy, and guidance from nan University of California, Berkeley, and his BA grade successful biology studies, English, and biology from St. Olaf College.

More