Surprise! Your Health Care Provider Added A Fee For That Questionnaire You Filled Out

By Michelle Crouch

Co-published with The Charlotte Ledger

When Steve Hardman of Charlotte checked successful to spot a Novant Health slumber expert earlier this year, nan receptionist handed him a study to capable out.

Hardman, 66, had seen nan questions earlier — Do you consciousness safe successful your house? Can you spend food? He spent a fewer minutes checking disconnected nan answers and handed nan shape backmost to nan beforehand desk.

A fewer weeks later, nan measure arrived, and it included an other $8 interest he hadn’t seen before.

Thinking it must beryllium a mistake, Hardman called Novant’s billing office. The billing typical told him nan interest was connected to nan questionnaire he had completed.

Hardman was shocked, particularly since nary 1 astatine Novant had talked to him astir nan study aliases his responses.

“You are asking group if they consciousness safe, if they tin spend food. Then you complaint them,” he said. “In what world does that really make sense?”

He said it sounded for illustration a strategy to boost revenue: “It’s only a mini amount, but you multiply that by I-don’t-know-how-many patients — astir apt millions each twelvemonth — and that’s a bully adhd to nan bottommost line.”

A nationalist trend

Across nan country, hospitals person started charging for self-administered questionnaires — little surveys that surface for depression, nutrient insecurity, home unit aliases different risks, said Caitlin Donovan, elder head astatine nan Patient Advocate Foundation, a patients’ authorities nonprofit.

The screenings are expected to emblem patients who request other support, but galore group don’t study astir immoderate imaginable fees until nan measure arrives. 

Donovan said she has talked to patients from aggregate states disappointment that they were billed for checking a fewer boxes. She said it’s portion of a broader billing inclination her statement has noticed of wellness attraction systems billing for items that utilized to beryllium included successful nan visit, whether it’s a facility fee aliases a complaint for messaging your doctor.

“They’re screening for intelligence wellness aliases safety, and that’s incredibly important, but it should beryllium portion of nan interest for nan visit, not an add-on,” Donovan said. “They cognize if it’s a small-enough amount, astir group astir apt conscionable salary it.”

Novant: Surveys thief patients

When asked astir nan charges, a Novant Health spokesperson said successful an email that nan study asking astir safety, lodging and nutrient information became a billable work successful 2024.

“Social determinants of wellness assessments uncover non-medical factors affecting well-being, connecting patients to societal workers, organization wellness workers, and section resources arsenic appropriate,” she wrote.

For example, she explained, patients facing nutrient insecurity are connected to nutrient resources and, if it’s urgent, provided pinch an emergency battalion that includes a four-day proviso of food. To date, Novant Health has provided astir 16,000 emergency nutrient packs, according to nan email.

The infirmary said astir security providers screen nan assessment, “and nan mostly of patients salary betwixt $5 and $10.”

UNC Health and Cone Health do akin screenings, but do not complaint separately for them, according to spokespeople astatine each hospital. Other North Carolina wellness attraction systems queried by nan Charlotte Ledger/NC Health News did not respond successful clip for publication.

Different types of assessments

After Hardman posted astir his acquisition connected nan NextDoor site, much than 153 group commented, including immoderate pinch akin experiences.

“I was billed by them arsenic well,” 1 female wrote. “They charged my security institution for their portion and maine nan balance.”

Another shared a photograph of a measure pinch a $17 interest and said, “They conscionable asked nan modular questions: Are you depressed? Have you had suicidal feelings?” she said. “And each of a abrupt location is simply a complaint for it without immoderate warning.”

Donovan said providers tin measure for respective different types of assessments. Some surface for alleged “social determinants of health,” for illustration nutrient and lodging insecurity. Others surface for intelligence wellness problems for illustration slump aliases anxiety.

Research shows intelligence wellness screening surveys tin lead to earlier discovery of intelligence wellness issues and much timely interventions. A 2022 study published successful nan Journal of Clinical Psychiatry found that regular usage of little screenings successful superior attraction settings accrued nan recognition of slump and worry disorders by 35 percent, starring to faster curen initiation and improved outcomes.

Novant said successful a connection that its affectional wellness appraisal “plays a cardinal domiciled successful identifying early signs of affectional aliases intelligence wellness concerns, allowing for timely support and intervention.”

Nearly 27 percent of patients who return nan appraisal surface affirmative for a intelligence wellness condition, nan infirmary said, “underscoring nan value of this screening and nan attraction team’s follow-up.”

“How was I expected to cognize astir nan charge?”

Heidi Bass, 59, of Charlotte agrees nan screenings are valuable, but she said what’s missing is transparency. 

The $17 complaint connected Bass’ aesculapian bill

She said she discovered a $17 complaint for a “brief affectional and behavioral wellness assessment” only aft clicking done respective screens to get a elaborate breakdown of nan measure for her yearly beingness astatine Novant earlier this year. 

When she called to inquire what nan interest was for, she talked to respective labor earlier 1 yet told her it was tied to nan questionnaire she completed during nan online check-in process.

“When I protested, they said, ‘You don’t person to capable it out.’ But really was I expected to cognize astir nan charge?” she said. “In nary different situations do we do thing and only find retired afterwards really overmuch it costs.”

Some insurers won’t pay

Medical billing master Adria Gross, CEO of New York-based MedWise Insurance Advocacy, said Medicare and Medicaid typically screen nan costs for nan screenings. 

But immoderate commercialized insurers whitethorn diminution to salary a abstracted interest because they expect specified screenings to beryllium “bundled” into nan wide sojourn charge, she said, which intends nan further costs would get passed on to nan patient.

“Insurers will besides contradict costs if nan screening is done excessively often aliases without archiving that personification reviewed nan results,” she said. “It really varies from argumentation to policy.”

Patients pinch high-deductible commercialized security plans whitethorn besides person to salary retired of pouch if they haven’t yet met their deductible.

Gross recommends that patients reappraisal their bills, mobility charges they don’t understand and inquire for immoderate they disagree pinch to beryllium waived.

That’s what Hardman did, and he said Novant dropped nan interest erstwhile he disputed it. 

He already has a plan, he said, if a receptionist tries to manus him a study astatine early appointments: “I’ll conscionable diminution it.” 

This article is portion of a business betwixt The Charlotte Ledger and North Carolina Health News to produce original wellness attraction reporting. You tin support this effort with a tax-deductible donation. 

Republish our articles for free, online aliases successful print, nether a Creative Commons license.