My Egg, My Wife’s Womb, Our Baby: How We Found Our Way To Lesbian Motherhood

Trending 3 days ago

Late past year, it became my friend’s favourite statement trick. “Rosa’s going to person a babe adjacent week,” she’d opportunity to a group of group who didn’t cognize me. I’d watch their faces arsenic they tried to inconspicuously scan my body, detecting nary motion of a bump. “Congratulations!” they’d say, smiles tight, intelligibly wondering what different delusions I might person up my sleeve.

I was, however, astir to person a baby. At daybreak on a warm October day, our beautiful, 6lb 10oz, 19.5in‑long baby woman was born; tegument pinkish and taut, shriek bedewed and bright. I held my wife’s manus and caput arsenic our girl emerged from her assemblage – a girl who had initially travel from me.

We did what is known arsenic reciprocal IVF: a way to parenthood that is progressively being utilized by queer people. First, we each made embryos by retrieving our eggs and having them fertilised pinch philanthropist sperm. With “normal” IVF, nan embryo, if you’re fortunate capable to person made one, returns to nan assemblage that made nan eggs. With reciprocal IVF, there’s a assemblage switch that feels a touch Shakespearean, aliases sci-fi. You person your partner’s embryo instead.

Years ago, erstwhile nan thought of children – aliases nan chat of them – still felt for illustration playing a game, moving pieces connected a board, this is really my wife, Leah, and I decided we wanted to do it. Knowing thing could beryllium taken for granted, nan dream was that Leah would transportation my embryo, past I would transportation hers.

There are definite griefs you look erstwhile gay. If you are ambivalent astir having children, you can’t time off it up to destiny to spot whether 2 bodies cooperate. (There are tons of self-protective jokes: have we been doing it incorrect each this time? Should we effort a caller position?) While subject mightiness soon alteration this for immoderate pioneers – mice pups person been made from 2 males and 2 females – for now, you can’t “see your faces together”.

I had fears. What if, 1 day, my kid looked astatine maine and said I wasn’t their existent mum? (Psychological mentation tells america this is simply a normal developmental phase, but, a much harrowing thought, what if I shared nan worry?) What if grandparents, too, felt nan difference? What if they showed it? What if, what if, what if – as if anything about having children tin ever beryllium controlled aliases predicted.

Reciprocal IVF seemed for illustration a measurement astir these worries. (My worries, I should say. For a worrier, Leah ne'er worried.) This way, we would some person an irrefutable narration pinch our children. Each time, 1 of america would beryllium genetically related, and the other would person had a acold larger impact: she would person transformed a cluster of cells into a baby. Folded into this were elements of magic we could both get behind; butterfly effects that are still nan taxable of young science: epigenetics – nan measurement uterine conditions “turn connected or off” familial markers, efficaciously making nan gestational mother a cistron DJ – and besides microchimerism. Through nan placenta, mini numbers of cells would walk from mother to babe and babe to mother, and enactment location for ever.

When I described to a beloved philosopher friend really Leah and I wanted to person children, he described it arsenic “the astir delightful task of mutuality”. I deliberation of this often.

Leah sitting cross-legged adjacent a model holding their babe daughter, pinch Rosa lying connected nan level adjacent to them pinch her caput connected Leah’s knee, holding Mara’s hand
Rosa Rankin-Gee (lying down) pinch her wife, Leah, and their daughter, Mara. Photograph: Celeste Sloman/The Guardian

I ever talk frankly astir really we had our girl – often volunteering nan accusation earlier personification asks – because, comparatively speaking, location are still truthful fewer models. Even successful New York, successful 2025, astatine a session galore of our lesbian friends person used, we were still an anomaly. When Leah was pregnant, we went to a lesbian wedding, and her belly was for illustration a billboard. So galore queer couples came up to america and asked america really we’d done it. They wanted details. We gave them gladly. Long-distance telephone calls pinch complete strangers were organised. Google docs were shared.

It felt important for some of america that we usage a known philanthropist – personification we knew personally, alternatively than going done a sperm bank. We thought astir nan qualities we were astir looking for successful a personification who would change our lives truthful immeasurably: knowability (we wanted them not to consciousness for illustration a enigma to us) and happiness or, astatine least, affectional steadiness, and, with luck, entree to joy. Small things, immense things, everything. When you autumn successful love, your assemblage decides for you. In this situation, you’re looking rationally, knowing that immoderate – whoever – comes from nan determination is nan consequence of clear-eyed volition alternatively than misty-eyed intangibility. And yet there’s ever a touch of nan intangible, too.

We scattered seeds into nan wind, without asking anyone directly. We hoped to find a donor, we told group erstwhile they asked, who was a friend, and who would go for illustration a godfather to our children. Reactions seemed truthful instinctive: “Oh wow, I could ne'er do that!” (noted) aliases “That would beryllium my perfect measurement of becoming a father” (also noted). Sometimes a joke would beryllium made – “Well, if you ever request … ” – and we’d effort to parse if it was a genuine connection aliases not.

We listened to their instincts, and to our own. With nan conversations that went a small deeper, really did nan move feel? Did we want nan aforesaid things?

The beloved friend we yet chose – and who chose us, because it was an embracing yes from each progressive – I finally asked much straight astatine a friend’s birthday. “More” being nan operative connection – I was still shy, elliptical – but I admitted location was a shortlist, and it was very short indeed, and of people he had agelong been connected it; really did he consciousness astir that? Beyond a oversea of different merits – generosity, a gregariousness that seems to travel from different century, a look that’s a pleasance to onshore connected – he had ever asked nan champion questions. All of which were astir nan early child, and what they mightiness want and need.

An administrative battle people followed. Tests, counselling, consent forms and contracts, truthful battery-like I deliberation I almost blocked them out. There was nan donation, which progressive laughter and inappropriate applause. There were our ovum retrievals, little than 24 hours isolated (egg retrievals are finely calibrated to a menstrual cycle, and for nan first clip successful our 8 years arsenic a couple, arsenic if they were successful connected nan full thing, our periods started connected nan aforesaid time that month). Then, successful a petri crockery successful Manhattan, our eggs were mixed pinch his sperm to make our embryos.

The family connected a broad connected writer adjacent a river, Rosa opinionated up holding Mara pinch her hands underneath baby’s stomach, and Leah lying connected a broad looking up astatine them
Photograph: Celeste Sloman/The Guardian

IVF is characterised by waiting. Fewer eggs than you commencement pinch mature, and past less than that fertilise, and less than that make it to 5 days, and each nan while you wonderment if this is really you observe you tin ne'er person a baby astatine all. You wonder, successful our case, really you will consciousness if it useful for 1 of us, but not nan other. Better, you show yourself – 2 wombs, 2 sets of ovaries, we’re lucky, we’re fortunate – but you besides cognize it’s not arsenic elemental arsenic that.

In nan end, we were lucky. We sewage nan numbers we needed. And 1 time past January, 1 of my embryos – they gave america a photograph; a grey-scale, blurry-looking thing, for illustration an oculus floater astir to hatch – was put wrong Leah pinch a aesculapian type of a pea-shooter. We ate nan McDonald’s fries that Reddit fertility forums committedness are lucky, and we waited for 10 days.

When we sewage nan reply – astatine nan Metropolitan Museum of Art, of each places, a instrumentality test, successful nan bathroom, because we couldn’t hold immoderate longer – it was unusual really shocked we felt, erstwhile truthful overmuch had gone into making this happen. I looked astatine nan faint lines and walked astir nan depository successful a daze.

This was nan infinitesimal our bodies began to separate. While Leah was continually alert of nan cells doubling wrong her arsenic they moved from poppy seed to saccharine pea to plum, my life was still unaffected. I entered Dad‑land. I was technically, physically, hormonally, astatine a region from each of it, a peculiarly funny sensation arsenic a woman. “The only mother-to-be who tin observe pinch champagne and sushi,” I’d say, or, “I’m drinking for three!” (It is simply a occurrence Leah stayed with me.)

Of people nan reality was much complicated: a man mightiness watch his pregnant partner propulsion up from greeting sickness and think, “That looks horrible, but there’s thing I tin do astir it.” I would watch Leah and think, “We made a prime for you to beryllium nan personification doing this.” I’d want to beryllium capable to return nan discomfort into my ain body. And yet I couldn’t and I hadn’t. Not this time, anyway. I worried she was resentful. I interrogated her astir this. “No,” she’d say. “This is nan champion point I person ever done.” She mightiness region to vomit again, and past say, truthful confusingly to me, because she really meant it, “You’re going to really emotion it.”

She did emotion it. She was bonzer pregnant. She ended up successful nightclubs much often than she had successful nan full erstwhile decade. She wore harvest tops for the first clip since she was 13. She hardly sewage retired of breath walking up nan 5 flights of stairs to our apartment. She didn’t get backmost pain. She hardly complained. “It’s not fair,” I would sometimes opportunity to her, knowing I was expected to spell next, “you’re mounting outrageously precocious standards.”

This is astatine erstwhile nan upside and nan downside. There was a basal knowing but besides a early accord – do unto maine arsenic I would do unto you. A beautiful intertwining: solidarity, kinship, compassion but, also, comparison. Another unhelpful point I said to Leah on a time erstwhile she was peculiarly tired, and I was idly reasoning astir nan future: “When I have to do this, we’ll also person a toddler.” She did not appreciate that.

In nan very fewer accounts I’ve publication of reciprocal IVF, location are stories of insensitive comments: “Who’s nan existent mum?”; “Where’s nan existent dad?” We haven’t had galore of those. On countless occasions, friends – and I truly don’t deliberation they were humouring america – seemed to hide that Leah and I couldn’t person a kid naturally. “Hope nan kid gets your X and her Y,” they mightiness say, putting our characteristics connected an imaginary collage, earlier 1 of america mightiness punctual them it’s technically impossible, aliases they’d realise themselves.

And erstwhile group affectionately telephone maine “the dad”, I haven’t minded. At a commencement class, wherever each nan men without neglect were successful shot caps, I liked nan gruff measurement they acknowledged me, pinch dips of their brims (I was wearing a shot cap, too). I’ve recovered fathers much forthcoming than I would person imagined. Many person said to me, kindly, “Don’t interest if you don’t consciousness thing till they’re astir six months old,” which I found shocking, but besides generous successful nan frankness. “It will happen,” was their regular refrain.

It was surely happening. Spring came, and Leah felt nan first “quickening” – nan babe moved, for illustration a frog betwixt her hands, she told me, but wrong her. For a while, I had to beryllium distant from Leah, and erstwhile I came location her belly was undeniable. She took my manus to her tegument – and for nan first clip I, too, felt movement. A shock, for illustration a digit had flicked maine from wrong her.

There were times I’d felt a consciousness of injustice that we had to impact anyone other successful our family-making, but successful that instant I felt this slice away. Whoever was successful location was real, and coming, and it was truthful overmuch little analyzable than I had imagined it mightiness be: they were so intelligibly ours.

I would find myself looking astatine Leah and our kid increasing wrong her and emotion a 2nd shock: that it was possible. For much than half my life I wouldn’t person imagined that. Even though I grew up successful London, pinch wide parents, it was a different time.

When we walked down nan street, I would put my limb astir Leah – protective but besides possessive. A stronger desire than accustomed to say, “We’re not conscionable friends.” This is my baby, too. We’ve done it.

She did it. The moments earlier our girl was born, I looked astatine Leah and felt nan astir precise and sweeping emotion I person ever felt.

Our daughter, Mara, looks for illustration me, particularly erstwhile she frowns. When she came out, her blond hairsbreadth was lacquered to her caput successful curls not acold from mine. They opportunity babies can’t really spot overmuch for months, but it feels arsenic if they are fixed a grace play successful nan first hours aliases so. I held her connected my forearm, her soft caput successful my hand, and we stared astatine each other.

I look astatine her still – she is nan proud proprietor of 2 bottommost teeth, razor-sharp seed pearls, and she smiles astatine each nan incorrect things. I spot nan sideways glimpse that runs done my dad’s family; her delicate bird‑likeness recalls my mum. But nan sum is vastly greater than nan parts: she is truthful decidedly her ain person.

Years ago, reasoning astir babies purely theoretically, I utilized to judge that “my” babe would beryllium my familial child, and “her” babe would beryllium Leah’s familial child. While Mara feels wholly for illustration our child, if she’s anyone’s, she’s Leah’s – Leah has known her successful a different, longer way. She made her pinch her body. When they are apart, she tin consciousness wherever Mara is, arsenic if her assemblage were a compass and Mara were north. I watch them – 1 successful a bed, 1 successful a bassinet – and they slumber pinch their arms successful precisely nan aforesaid way.

My fearfulness astir grandparents was profoundly unfounded, too: I person ne'er seen a purer emotion than Leah’s mother’s for Mara. When Mara was a newborn, erstwhile we near them together, to shop aliases navigator aliases nap, they would ever beryllium successful nan nonstop aforesaid position erstwhile we came back, no gap betwixt them.

For each nan elements of fairytale, it’s not without complications. For 2 women for illustration us, whose information is only “social infertility”, location are acold little medically invasive ways to get pregnant. Any IVF gestation is considered higher risk, and being a surrogate is higher consequence still, but some things, erstwhile it comes to 2 women having a family together, are understudied.

The family sitting connected a greenish rattan spot connected a veranda, Rosa connected nan near sitting cross-legged, Leah connected nan correct holding Mara successful betwixt them
Photograph: Celeste Sloman/The Guardian

It won’t matter really you made nan babe erstwhile it comes, group told us, and I deliberation that’s right. Because erstwhile nan kid exists they are nan kid they are, and they couldn’t beryllium immoderate other. At nan start, possibly I was drawn to reciprocal IVF because it was nan closest we could get to what consecutive couples tin person naturally. But, successful reality, it ne'er felt for illustration a mimic aliases replication. It felt – it feels – very overmuch for illustration its ain thing. That intertwining again. An overseas echo of nan DNA helix but without DNA really changing – aliases overmuch of it. Unlike Leah, I don’t consciousness I request to beryllium pregnant to beryllium a mother; I’ve proved that. But I emotion nan equilibrium of it, nan symmetry. If there’s familial primacy, it extends nan different measurement now: I emotion what it will mean to transportation her child, pinch her genes. For her DNA to participate mine.

We do not cognize what nan early will bring. The conversations that will beryllium unexpectedly easy, aliases hard. Where first worries person melted, caller ones person grown successful their place. The classics – erstwhile I spell to her successful nan nighttime will she still beryllium breathing? – and nan modern classics – caller wars, and resurfacing fears astir having a kid successful this world arsenic a cheery couple.

We are some connected Mara’s commencement certificate. But, to beryllium safe, I will person to adopt my ain daughter, which is some costly and simply strange. When moving retired Mara’s afloat sanction for her passport, we plotted 2 paths: really we mightiness each beryllium capable to recreation pinch Mara unsocial and beryllium recognised arsenic her parent, but besides really we mightiness beryllium capable to recreation arsenic a family yet walk for consecutive – cousins, friends – if we needed to recreation to a state wherever being cheery is illegal.

Seismic shifts towards conservatism make having a family for illustration ours consciousness political. I clasp galore ideas successful my head: nan mundanity, nan miraculousness, nan newness of really we did it, nan oldness of what we did. This summer, nan astir delightful task of mutuality will hopefully continue. This time, if luck takes our manus again, Leah gets to portion nan vino and eat nan cheese.

More