Long- Vs Short-stroke Engines: What Are The Differences?

Matveev Aleksandr/Shutterstock

Just astir each piston motor is defined by 2 basal measurements: bore and stroke. Bore is nan diameter of nan cylinder. Stroke is nan region nan piston travels from bottommost dormant halfway to apical dormant center. Introduce a spot of math, including cylinder count, and those measurements yet lead america to nan wide displacement of an engine. 

When bore and changeable are equal, nan motor is described arsenic "square." A agelong changeable is called an undersquare, meaning that nan changeable is importantly longer than nan bore, and a short changeable is called an oversquare, meaning it has a bore larger than nan stroke.

When comparing long-stroke and short-stroke engines, and their associated benefits and drawbacks, it's useful to comparison engines of adjacent displacement. That way, we tin talk astir the changes successful bore and stroke as they subordinate to each other, and really those differences successful motor creation person effects connected power, efficiency, and packaging.

Matveev Aleksandr/Shutterstock

An summation successful nan region a piston travels wrong nan cylinder, aka nan changeable length, besides increases nan stresses acting connected nan piston and crankshaft. The longer nan stroke, nan much inertia has to beryllium managed wrong nan cylinder. This is 1 of nan main reasons why long changeable engines are not designed to rev very high.

A short-stroke motor has little inertial stress. Since nan piston has little region to travel, nan acceleration of nan piston is little astatine nan aforesaid rpm. All different factors being equal, this intends that nan motor tin rev to a higher rpm earlier accent becomes a limiting factor. Short-stroke engines person an advantage wherever motor manufacturers are looking to maximize power, because powerfulness output is straight linked to motor velocity — higher rpm intends much horsepower. Some of your favourite high-revving supercars apt person short stroke. 

However, motor velocity isn't nan complete picture. Stroke magnitude besides affects valve timing and combustion behavior, each of which style performance. 

mizanul khoir/Shutterstock

So, nan bottommost extremity of an engine, pinch its cylinders and crankshaft person inertial stresses to woody with. Then, there's nan effect bore has connected nan apical extremity and components for illustration valves. Larger bore cylinders person much room for valves, which modulate nan travel of aerial and substance into nan combustion chamber. Larger valves let for increased airflow into nan cylinder.

Short-stroke engines straight use from this. Since their larger bores consequence successful amended breathing, they tin create powerfulness astatine higher rpms. The other happens pinch agelong changeable engines. Since they person smaller bores, their valve sizes and resulting aerial travel is limited. Generally, this constricted airflow is what makes long-stroke engines constricted successful their accumulation of power. 

There are besides nan effects that bore and changeable person connected turbulence. Turbulence is fundamentally nan activity of nan air-fuel substance wrong nan cylinder. Smaller bores and deeper chambers clasp longer turbulence and springiness faster combustion. Cylinders pinch larger bores and flatter chambers beforehand speedy decay of turbulence. Earlier ignition timing is required to antagonistic that, but that is besides a double-edged sword, since it exposes nan piston crown and nan cylinder caput to power for longer periods. This summation successful vulnerability tin lead to an summation successful power nonaccomplishment and a alteration successful efficiency. 

Andrey Grigoriev/Getty Images

A persistent belief is that long-stroke engines inherently nutrient much torque. That is not ever true. Differences successful bore and changeable consequence successful changes successful pressure, arsenic good arsenic lengthening aliases shortening of nan effective lever arm, and those effects cancel each different retired erstwhile nan displacement stays nan same. So changeable magnitude by itself does not find torque.

What does disagree is wherever torque is produced. Ever heard nan word "low-end torque"? Long changeable engines typically scope their highest torque astatine little rpm. Smaller bores and valves limit precocious velocity breathing, but nan combustion process is good suited to little motor speeds and a beardown torque transportation astatine debased rpm. This is why, erstwhile astir group deliberation of long-stroke engines, they deliberation of relaxed capacity astatine debased speeds. This is besides portion of the logic why semi trucks don't usage V8s, arsenic nan debased RPMs put little strain connected their engine, expanding reliability and decreasing operating costs.

FooTToo/Shutterstock

As bore and changeable vary, truthful does friction. A longer changeable increases piston recreation distance, raising friction. By limiting nan region a piston has to move, short-stroke engines person reduced clash and windage. Windage is nan aerial guidance that nan piston faces arsenic it moves wrong nan cylinder, and for illustration friction, it tin origin nonaccomplishment of power wrong nan engine. Another measurement short changeable engines negociate nan nonaccomplishment of power is pinch a smaller crankshaft throw, which results successful rotating components moving done a smaller arc. 

Another rumor to support successful mind is cooling. If nan aboveground area of a piston is smaller, it's easier to cool. But as bore size increases, truthful does nan region power must recreation from nan piston crown to nan cylinder wall. 

Long changeable engines pinch smaller bores use from easier piston cooling and reduced power concentration. There's intelligibly a equilibrium betwixt these 2 dimensions: bore and stroke. Each has its benefits and drawbacks, and automakers person to creation engines pinch each nan subject and mathematics successful mind.