I Went Undercover As A Cleaner At A Failing Care Home. Here's What I Witnessed

Trending 1 month ago

Catriona MacPheeBBC Scotland Disclosure

BBC Photo of Catriona successful nan attraction home. The photograph is simply a selfie which appears to person been taken pinch nan camera balanced n a table. The inheritance shows nan interior of nan location pinch her cleaner's trolley behind. Catriona is dressed successful a bluish overall.BBC

Catriona often recovered residents lying successful bedewed apparel aliases connected soiled sheets

In my 7 weeks undercover successful an overstretched attraction location I witnessed galore scenes of mediocre attraction and distress but location was 1 incident that I fishy will stay pinch maine for a agelong time.

On nan worst days, erstwhile staffing was astatine its lowest levels, nan residents would sometimes outcry for thief arsenic they heard my cleaning trolley rumbling past their rooms.

Some were hopeless for thief to spell to nan toilet, others simply wanted to get washed and dressed for nan day.

As a cleaner, location was small I could do isolated from connection words of comfortableness and assurances that I'd told nan attraction staff.

One time I sat pinch a female successful a nightie who needed thief to beryllium taken from her furniture to nan bathroom, conscionable 8ft away.

Her room echoed pinch signs of a life good lived - a proud career, overseas holidays pinch her loving family, an immaculately curated wardrobe of cashmere cardigans.

As we waited for a carer to come, she begged maine not to leave.

She was becoming progressively uncomfortable.

I tried to distract her pinch mini talk astir nan position and nan weather.

She listened until she could nary longer hide her distress.

As her beingness capacity to hold for nan toilet yet crumbled, she began to sob.

I felt sadness galore times successful nan attraction location but that wholly avoidable nonaccomplishment of dignity was nan first clip I felt anger.

Our investigation was sparked by an question and reply pinch Susan Christie, whose begetter spent 2 years successful Castlehill, nan largest attraction location successful Inverness.

It is billed arsenic a luxury location and charges up to £1,800 per week.

But Susan had go truthful concerned by nan modular of her father's attraction that she installed a concealed camera successful his room - and she was appalled by what she saw.

"He wasn't being washed properly, he was being near successful an incontinence pad for successful excess of 12 hours, ne'er taken to nan toilet, nutrient placed retired of reach, spilling basking porridge connected himself," she told us.

"It was neglect."

The last straw came erstwhile a cleaner was filmed restraining nan aged man and violently shaking nan furniture framework earlier prodding him pinch a stepping stick.

He was later sacked and Susan had 9 complaints upheld by nan Care Inspectorate.

She moved her begetter retired of Castlehill successful May.

In bid to comparison Castlehill to nan 1,000 different attraction homes crossed Scotland, nan BBC sent a Freedom of Information petition to assemblage regulator, nan Care Inspectorate, to inquire which attraction homes successful Scotland had nan astir complaints upheld against them.

Castlehill topped nan database pinch 10 complaints upheld successful 2024.

We interviewed a further 4 families who each had stories of akin concerns - but they were each historical.

The only measurement to judge whether this was still going connected was to spell successful and spot for ourselves.

We went done nan rigorous BBC soul processes of asking for support to secretly film.

There was judged to beryllium a important nationalist liking successful evidence-gathering of this nature.

Undercover filming shows distressed attraction location resident

In May I recovered myself phoning nan attraction location to inquire if location were immoderate cleaning jobs going.

I was invited for an question and reply and asked to commencement immediately.

At nan aforesaid time, nan location was successful typical measures owed to betterment notices issued by nan Care Inspectorate complete a scope of issues.

They were nether nan spotlight - surely things would improve?

What I recovered was an understaffed location that didn't person nan correct operation of unit to woody pinch nan basal needs of residents, peculiarly those pinch dementia.

This was starring to distress, fierce behaviour and situation situations.

As I wheeled my cleaning trolley information nan corridors, I was acutely alert of pleading faces peering retired of bedrooms, hoping for a fewer minutes of institution and conversation.

Those people, astatine least, still hoped for a infinitesimal of quality connection. I came to realise others had fixed up.

An exterior changeable of a ample modern attraction home

Castlehil is nan largest attraction location successful Inverness and charges up to £1,800 per week

One time I reassured a man who needed nan toilet: "I've told nan carers, they opportunity they're coming."

"Aye, truthful is Christmas," he replied.

Of each nan things I tried to hole for earlier going undercover I hadn't anticipated forming genuine bonds pinch nan group who lived successful there.

The reality of this deed maine 1 time while I sat successful my car connected a break and I was overwhelmed pinch emotion.

Earlier, while cleaning 1 resident's room, I recovered myself retching because of nan smell, incapable to enactment for longer than 20 seconds.

The once-proud Highland man whose room it was had been served his meal and had spent hours sitting unsocial successful there.

Nobody had thought to unfastened his curtains aliases windows.

At slightest I could locomotion retired of location astatine nan extremity of my shift. They couldn't.

Catriona worked for 7 weeks arsenic a cleaner astatine nan attraction home

Catriona worked for 7 weeks arsenic a cleaner astatine nan attraction home

During my clip successful nan home, I often recovered residents lying successful bedewed apparel aliases connected soiled sheets.

I heard women screaming from down closed doors because antheral carers were doing their friendly care.

The effect of overstretched unit was clear.

They had had a tick database of tasks to complete and often that was excessively agelong to see meaningful engagement, support pinch eating aliases unhurried continence care.

There were immoderate carers who strove to make nan lives of residents amended and who managed to carve retired clip successful their engaged days to prosecute but those moments were fewer and acold between.

Carers were paid £13 an hr to do friendly individual care, and overmuch more, for group pinch very analyzable needs. This is successful statement pinch manufacture standards.

I interviewed Donald McAskill of Scottish Care for nan BBC Disclosure investigation.

One of his quotes has stuck pinch me.

"You tin get much for stepping a canine done nan meadows of Edinburgh than you tin from sitting astatine somebody's bedside, holding their manus arsenic they respire their last," he said.

"For me, I find that obscene."

room mess

Staff often did not person clip to walk clip pinch residents

The experts we interviewed were unanimous connected 1 issue. They said nan attraction assemblage is successful crisis.

They cited underfunding, unit shortages and unprecedented cuts to frontline dementia support services.

With a backdrop of rising request for attraction - nan number of group pinch dementia is predicted to double by 2040 - each of nan master contributors successful our movie called for a nationwide speech connected nan early of nan sector.

Families often told maine that they had nary action but to spot their loved ones successful a attraction home.

It hadn't really been a choice, it was nan consequence of a situation aliases a deficiency of attraction support astatine home.

The guilt weighed heavy connected them, arsenic did nan load of nan analyzable financial arrangements that travel pinch attraction homes.

It's a business that has, aliases will, touch astir families astatine immoderate point.

urine footprints

Pools of urine connected a attraction location corridor

The occupation was not each punishment and gloom.

In my last week, a caller activity leader began staging euphony concerts and playing nan mandolin successful nan lounges, to nan awesome joyousness of immoderate residents.

A caller lawman head besides group her mind to nan task of tackling nan smell of urine that permeated nan first floor.

The residents were nan unexpected item who kept maine going erstwhile I recovered it difficult to support stepping backmost done nan beforehand doors of Castlehill.

One man stopped maine successful nan corridor to show maine astir his volunteering activity and really overmuch he enjoyed this clip helping others.

As we laughed astir nan situations he'd recovered himself in, he abruptly trim nan speech short.

He said his autobus was owed immoderate infinitesimal and he didn't want to miss it.

It dawned connected maine that he thought we were 2 strangers chatting astatine nan autobus stop.

Despite that not being nan case, we some took joyousness from that quality connection.

I learned that pinch a fewer minutes of your time, you could promote personification retired of their ammunition aliases easiness their confusion.

That was each it took for them to locomotion distant pinch a smile, aliases astatine slightest calmer than erstwhile they first approached you.

bear

Catriona said residents conscionable wanted a quality connection

When I worked successful nan location I wore a concealed camera, which was signaling for astir of nan time.

I worried that personification mightiness spot nan hidden lens, aliases nan artillery would autumn retired of my clothes.

Luckily neither of those things happened.

On 1 juncture I forgot to deterioration nan clone glasses I had adopted arsenic a partial disguise.

I'm from nan Highlands and was worried that personification from my location municipality would travel into nan location and recognise me, truthful nan disguise gave maine a mini reassurance.

Half measurement done a unit meeting, personification asked really I could spot decently without my glasses connected today?

I bumbled my measurement done an mentation of not having had my java yet and leaving them successful nan car by mistake. It was a sloppy correction that I didn't repeat.

There were days erstwhile nan camera failed, aliases nan artillery ran out.

There were different days erstwhile I had to thief nan residents first and foremost, and was not capable to move nan camera on.

I was clear connected 1 point from nan outset - my privilege had to beryllium nan residents and their needs.

That was nan full constituent of nan investigation. Filming was secondary.

There were immoderate incidents of mediocre attraction that I did not grounds connected camera but I near pinch a clear conscience.

It was a privilege of this domiciled to concisely transverse paths pinch interesting, funny and charming characters, who led rich | and colourful lives.

We sang songs together, danced successful nan corridor, hugged, discussed each mode of topics - from Caravaggio and Gaelic lessons to Donald Trump and canine stepping - and laughed, lots.

Without realising it, nan residents kept maine going done a difficult job.

I near Castlehill Care Home connected 9 August.

As I walked retired nan doors for nan last time, 1 mobility repeated successful my mind - surely they merit better?

'Significant improvements made successful nan past 3 months'

A spokesperson for Castlehill Care Home, which trades nether nan sanction Simply Inverness, said: "We are appalled by nan footage aired successful nan BBC programme.

"It was not provided to america successful beforehand and does not bespeak nan business today.

"The safety, wellness and wellbeing of residents remains our absolute privilege astatine each times.

"The Care Inspectorate has recognised nan important improvements made successful nan past 3 months.

"We must guarantee that these improvements are sustained.

"In excess of £1m is being invested successful nan refurbishment of nan location and we convey each residents and their families for their patience during nan renovations."

A spokesperson for nan Highland Health and Social Care Partnership said: "The contented of nan BBC Disclosure documentary astir Castlehill Care Home which highlighted issues astir transportation of safe, value attraction was concerning for each to see, and we understand really profoundly distressing this will person been for families of those residents.

"We person a work arsenic a cardinal partner pinch regards to support and protection of adults and we person clear expectations of standards to beryllium met by immoderate attraction location supplier successful Highland.

"The supplier of Castlehill attraction location did not meet those standards.

"At this clip attraction location admissions stay suspended and will proceed until we are perfectly assured that nan required standards person been met and sustained."

If you person been affected by nan issues raised successful this story, accusation and support tin beryllium recovered astatine the BBC's Action Line.

More