Final Ruling Ends Two-decade Battle Over Legal Status Of Hotel In Alcudia

The Supreme Court successful Madrid has upheld a ruling by nan Balearic High Court ordering nan closure of nan Botel Alcudiamar successful Puerto Alcudia, bringing an extremity to a prolonged ineligible conflict complete nan hotel’s authorisation to operate.

The lawsuit originated from a situation brought by nan biology group GOB, which based on that nan constitution had been granted tourer authorisation unlawfully and that nan tract was primitively designated exclusively for nautical use. The courts agreed, determining that nan edifice activity contravened readying and tourism laws.

Dates backmost to 2003

The conflict dates backmost to 2003, erstwhile tourer authorisation was issued to nan Botel Alcudiamar, by which clip nan spot was already functioning arsenic a hotel. Following years of ineligible proceedings, the Balearic High Court ruled earlier this twelvemonth that nan authorisation could not stay valid. In March 2025, nan tribunal instructed nan Council of Mallorca to return nan basal steps to adjacent nan constitution wrong 2 months.

Alcudiamar S.L., nan institution operating nan marina and nan hotel, appealed nan determination to nan Supreme Court. However, nan country’s highest judicial authority has now rejected that appeal, efficaciously confirming nan earlier ruling and requiring nan hotel’s closure. The institution has stated only that it intends to study nan determination earlier commenting further.

Supreme Court ruling

The Supreme Court’s judgement appears to reason a ineligible process lasting much than 2 decades, during which nan edifice continued to operate. The environmentalists down nan original lawsuit person maintained that nan Botel Alcudiamar’s tourer activity was incompatible pinch nan site’s approved use, which they opportunity was intended solely for nautical accommodation and services.

On 17 October, 2 days aft nan Supreme Court ruling was made public, GOB submitted a caller petition to nan Balearic High Court. In it, nan group called connected some nan Council of Mallorca and Alcudiamar S.L. to adjacent and seal nan hotel’s accommodation without further delay, arguing that enforcement of nan judgement should now proceed immediately.

The ruling reinforces nan Balearic High Court’s earlier conclusion that nan tourism usage of nan tract violated readying and biology regulations. It besides underlines nan judiciary’s position that nary backstage aliases firm liking tin override land-use designations established for nationalist aliases ecological protection.

The Botel Alcudiamar, situated wrong nan maritime-terrestrial nationalist domain, remains operational for now, pending enforcement of nan closure order. The Council of Mallorca has been directed to oversee compliance and guarantee nan cessation of edifice activity.

The Supreme Court’s determination marks a important precedent successful nan Balearic Islands, affirming judicial backing for biology protection and territorial regularisation successful coastal zones and concluding 1 of Mallorca’s longest-running readying disputes.