.png?2.1.1 "Vokash")
1 month ago
Wes Streeting, nan UK wellness secretary, was successful a authorities car heading backmost into cardinal London from a flag-raising to people nan UK’s nickname of Palestine erstwhile he saw nan news. “He was aghast,” an adjutant said. Streeting was reference connected his telephone that Donald Trump had conscionable warned women not to return Tylenol – known extracurricular nan US arsenic paracetamol – during pregnancy.
The US president had alleged without grounds that nan communal painkiller caused autism successful children. “Don’t return Tylenol,” Trump said astir a supplier besides known arsenic acetaminophen.
The British authorities has been criticised for tiptoeing astir Trump connected each mode of issues. But not, it seems, connected this. Streeting decided to devise a scheme to limit nan fallout successful nan UK and reassure mothers-to-be that taking paracetamol was safe. He decided to rebut – publically and vigorously – what Trump had said.
Already booked to look connected a meal show nan adjacent morning, Streeting knew he would beryllium asked astir Trump. “He knew he had to beryllium unequivocal,” nan adjutant said. “That immoderate negotiated issues we face, first and foremost our work is people’s health.”
‘Listen to doctors, scientists’
When nan mobility came, Streeting was brutal. “I spot doctors complete President Trump, frankly, connected this,” he said. “I’ve conscionable sewage to beryllium really clear astir this: location is nary grounds to nexus nan usage of paracetamol by pregnant women to autism successful their children. None.
“So I would conscionable opportunity to group watching: don’t salary immoderate attraction whatsoever to what Donald Trump says astir medicine. In fact, don’t moreover return my connection for it, arsenic a leader – perceive to British doctors, British scientists, nan NHS.”
His headline-making consequence to Trump’s baseless declare was complemented by a “flood nan airwaves” strategy that he and his Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) had begun putting successful spot nan time before.
Senior figures from bodies specified arsenic nan Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency, which regulates medicines, NHS England, nan Royal College of GPs, nan Royal Pharmaceutical Society and nan UK Health Security Agency conveyed akin messages to Streeting’s successful media interviews passim Tuesday.
The National Autistic Society criticised “the incessant misinformation astir autism from President Trump and [the US wellness secretary] Robert F Kennedy Jr”, which it said would undermine decades of investigation and time off autistic group “dismayed and frightened”.
Their responses aligned pinch those issued by nan World Health Organization (WHO) and leading aesculapian bodies successful nan US.
In addition, DHSC officials gave doctors and influencers pinch ample followings connected societal media factsheets and briefings connected paracetamol and gestation to thief guarantee they sewage accurate, well-evidenced accusation retired connected platforms specified arsenic X, TikTok and Instagram.
Recent months person brought respective high-profile examples of untruths astir medicine and specified misinformation is causing increasing siren successful nan world wellness community.
In June, crab doctors revealed their scary that immoderate patients were shunning established treatments for nan illness and alternatively opting for untested quack regimes specified arsenic java enemas and earthy juice diets.
Days later, nan BBC disclosed really Paloma Shemirani, nan girl of a caregiver turned anti-vaxxer, Kate Shemirani, had died aft rejecting chemotherapy for non-Hodgkin lymphoma. The 23-year-old had chosen to usage Gerson therapy, an unproven curen for cancer, instead.
And this period successful an quality connected nan main shape astatine Reform UK’s conference, nan cardiologist claimed that King Charles and nan Princess of Wales’s crab diagnoses were linked to them having had nan Covid vaccine.
But experts who study wellness misinformation spot Trump’s remarks arsenic a worrying caller low.
Helen Bedford, a professor of kid wellness astatine University College London (UCL), said: “I was horrified, because it’s not evidence-based and he is nan astir powerful man successful nan world. It was shocking because you cognize nan effect it’s going to have, not conscionable connected pregnant women but besides because it implies that autism is thing to beryllium avoided. It was a horrifying announcement, damaging and dangerous.”
Dr Susanna Kola-Palmer, a scientist astatine nan University of Huddersfield, said: “People are prone to authority bias, trusting and believing what personification successful authority says conscionable because they are an authority figure, not needfully because they are right. Donald Trump, arsenic nan US president, is simply a powerful nationalist fig and truthful tons of group will judge what he says without questioning it.
“When wellness misinformation is being peddled truthful publically by specified a powerful person, it is some profoundly troubling and dangerous, arsenic it risks eroding nationalist spot successful subject and compromising nationalist health.”
Health experts fearfulness Trump linking acetaminophen to autism could dissuade pregnant women – who already person fewer medicines disposable if they autumn sick – from utilizing it and successful move lead to illnesses specified arsenic symptom aliases a fever going untreated and harming them aliases their unborn child.
Pharmacists successful nan UK study that Trump’s remarks whitethorn already beryllium influencing immoderate people’s decisions astir their health. In a study of 500 pharmacies, 24% said they had encountered patients this week who were questioning paracetamol’s safety.
“These are alarming findings which show that comments made successful nan US are having a nonstop effect connected patients successful nan UK and perchance deterring immoderate from taking what are proven and safe aesculapian treatments,” said Olivier Picard, nan chair of nan National Pharmacy Association.
‘Fringe narratives’
Writing successful nan Lancet aesculapian diary successful July, Heidi Larson, a professor of anthropology astatine nan London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, identified nan US arsenic nan root of truthful overmuch of nan “pandemic of misinformation” and “fringe narratives” that caused contention during nan Covid pandemic and look to person gained moreover much traction since.
For example, from 2019to 2021 nan US acted arsenic “a awesome exporter of Covid-19 vaccine misinformation, pinch American accounts disproportionately represented arsenic cardinal hubs successful world misinformation networks”, she said. That influenced behaviour successful countries arsenic acold distant arsenic Nigeria, Ghana and Bulgaria, contributing to reduced uptake of Covid and puerility vaccines.
As a result, organisations specified arsenic nan WHO and Gavi, nan vaccines alliance, successful their day-to-day activity promoting vaccines “are progressively confronted by vaccine hesitancy grounded successful exported disinformation, overmuch of it straight traceable to American governmental sermon and media,” Larson said.
Concerted efforts to undermine vaccines are rising contempt nan WHO’s estimate that vaccines person saved 154 cardinal lives since 1974 – 101 cardinal of them children – and successful an era of accelerated advancement successful aesculapian subject erstwhile caller vaccines look to connection committedness connected diseases for which until precocious they were not used.
So really tin nan increasing threat misinformation poses to wellness worldwide beryllium tackled?
There is nary evident measurement to extremity nan authoritarian Trump and Kennedy promoting chaotic theories astir wellness contempt a deficiency of evidence. But experts opportunity caller approaches successful consequence are needed, particularly pinch large tech firms whose societal media platforms dispersed truthful overmuch of nan scaremongering. There is simply a statement that simply relying connected conveying meticulous accusation via leaflets and websites is not enough.
“While messages from Wes Streeting and master organisations are very helpful, grounds shows that what matters to nan nationalist is nan individual conversations they person pinch wellness professionals,” Bedford said, citing nan galore questions a genitor whitethorn person earlier their kid starts their schedule of vaccinations. “Most group spot wellness professionals and want to talk to them erstwhile they person concerns and questions. That tin beryllium very powerful and very influential.”
But she noted that nan UK has a shortage of galore types of wellness professionals – wellness visitant numbers person fallen sharply since 2015 – truthful really specified informative and perchance reassuring conversations would hap was not obvious. A different mindset among clinicians and a bigger wellness workforce were needed to alteration specified a displacement to pro-active, pre-treatment appointments, she said.
Chris van Tulleken, an NHS infectious diseases expert and world wellness master astatine UCL, cautioned that clinicians having specified conversations should not automatically disregard nan views of patients who whitethorn person suspicious, moreover conspiratorial views astir large pharma, fixed immoderate of its products person caused awesome harm.
“We person to meet group wherever they are. If you conscionable tweet pinch nan hashtag ‘vaccines work’, which immoderate group do, nan trouble is that location are immoderate vaccines pinch superior side-effects. I tally a session wherever we’re cautious astir definite vaccines,” he said.
Last twelvemonth nan WHO agreed a business pinch TikTok involving factchecking and nan societal media institution doing much to region contented that could endanger health.
The WHO’s Fides network brings together much than 1,000 wellness professionals who are progressive connected societal media “to amplify trustworthy contented and push backmost against harmful misinformation”, said Dr Alex Ruani, 1 of those involved. “It’s fundamentally a ‘trusted voices’ network.” For instance, Dr Mikhail “Mike” Varshavski, 1 of those voices, has much than 29 cardinal followers connected societal media.
Ruani said societal media platforms needed to do overmuch more. “Big tech already cognize really to downrank, demote, deamplify aliases quarantine content. These processes tin and should beryllium applied to high-risk contented [about health],” she said.
“We request amended consequence flags and warnings astatine nan constituent of exposure, a spot for illustration really you get pop-ups for cookies aliases really spam filters activity successful email. These clash nudges tin beryllium built into browsers aliases apps to springiness group a heads-up astir dodgy contented earlier they devour aliases stock it.”
English (US) · 
Indonesian (ID) ·