Consumer Reports Says Ev Reliability Is Still A Problem For These Reasons

BLKstudio/Shutterstock

Consumer Reports has been putting merchandise claims to nan trial for 90 years. The statement has seen a point aliases 2 erstwhile it comes to cars, including nan increasing pains that travel pinch method innovation. Which is why we should salary attraction erstwhile CR says that EVs are emotion those pains correct now.  

In nan December 4, 2025, section of nan Consumer Reports podcast "Talking Cars", nan unit collapsed down why caller EVs and PHEVs are still plagued by reliability issues, comparative to cars that trust connected accepted hybrid aliases combustion engines. Although we're summarizing immoderate cardinal points here, it's good worthy a listen, arsenic nan speech reveals a batch of nan nuanced considerations down nan barroom charts and trial information that millions of group consult each year.  

Building immoderate car is not easy. When you region a transmission, engine, and each those associated parts, 1 would deliberation things should go little complicated. Not so. EVs whitethorn not pain state — or arsenic much, successful nan lawsuit of PHEVs — but they're nary different from their combustion-powered counterparts successful that they trust connected a batch of components moving together to usability properly. 

And arsenic nan CR squad points out, galore of those parts and systems connected EVs are still successful their infancy. New batteries. New charging systems. New heating and ambiance systems. That's compounded by nan truth that putting them together is besides still a comparatively caller process, moreover for nan astir knowledgeable automakers. These are CR's reasons down caller EV reliability problems. What's absorbing is that contempt these challenges, CR information shows that galore owners emotion them anyway.

Primeimages/Getty Images

For EV skeptics — and a 41% driblet successful January EV registrations suggests location are plentifulness of them — each of this mightiness make it easy aliases convenient to constitute nan exertion off. That's not nan connection here. On nan contrary, Tesla cracked CR's apical 10 for caller car reliability for nan first clip since launching nan Roadster successful 2008. (Note that date. We'll revisit it.) The constituent is, refinement of each these analyzable systems takes time. We whitethorn deliberation astir EV motors, but little truthful astir everything else.   

Take heating, for example. EVs can't trust connected motor power for ambiance functions. Instead, they usage power pumps, aliases exertion akin to abstraction heaters, powered by nan battery. The artillery itself has to strengthen ambiance and operating cycles, while nan chargers and inverters person to usability properly. PHEVs characteristic EV and combustion motor for bugs to show up in. 

What CR makes clear is that immoderate caller exertion erstwhile nan bugs are worked out, things thin to get better. Those of america who person purchased a not-quite-perfect first exemplary twelvemonth of a redesign, and person a stack of warranty claims to beryllium it, cognize nan symptom that tin travel pinch being an early adopter — regardless of powertrain.

The bigger truth is, exertion isn't conscionable an EV problem, it's an manufacture problem. Recently, nan JD Power 2026 Dependability Study dropped, and revealed that caller cars are much problematic than ever. Period. The premier culprit? Infotainment, which accounted for much than double nan tally of nan second-highest problem area, exteriors. In summation to their ain peculiar issues, EVs and PHEVs are not immune to these package troubles arsenic well. 

happycreator/Shutterstock

Coming backmost to 2008, this was besides nan first twelvemonth that cars from South Korea — the Hyundai Elantra SE and Santa Fe — made CR's Top Picks. Relevance? Hyundai deed U.S. shores successful 1986. That intends it took some Hyundai and Tesla astir 20 years to found CR-worthy levels of reliability. And Tesla was caller from conscionable astir nan crushed up. This isn't a reflection connected EVs being inherently bad. It's a testament to really difficult it is for moreover nan largest automakers to benignant things out. Electrification is nary different, and immoderate versions of it are now afloat embraced. 

Around 25 years ago, nan Toyota Prius was an upstart, an unproven engineering marvel that looked for illustration a pouch protector connected wheels. Now? The Prius is hybrid perfection. You'll find hybrids up and down shaper lineups. They deficiency nan dedicated charging circuitry of PHEVs, and trust connected nan motor to powerfulness heating and aerial conditioning for illustration a regular state car. The exertion is robust, and if you're willing successful a fuel-efficient, reliable caller car that boasts electrification, CR says that hybrids are reliable to beat.

If you are into an EV aliases PHEV, it's besides important to statement that reliability doesn't beryllium successful a vacuum. For example, nan Consumer Reports information shows that nan Ford F-150 Hybrid has really precocious reliability scores, but debased proprietor satisfaction, while nan Mustang Mach-E has a very precocious reliability rating, and owners excavation it. Documented problems are problems, but this, and respective much examples for illustration it, suggests that — as pinch immoderate car — your ain usage lawsuit and expectations will facet into successful your wide ownership experience.