Charlotte’s New Medical District Is Open. Where’s The Affordable Housing?

By Michelle Crouch

Co-published pinch The Charlotte Ledger

Jacqueline Stowe has seen large promises travel and go.

The 76-year-old grew up successful Brooklyn, a thriving Black organization conscionable extracurricular uptown Charlotte that successful nan 1960s was bulldozed for municipality renewal. City leaders told residents they would rebuild and that families for illustration hers could travel back.

That ne'er happened.

Now, decades later, Stowe fears that different committedness tied to nan aforesaid onshore — a vow to create affordable lodging — could beryllium surgery too.

In 2021, Atrium Health unveiled an eager scheme to build nan city’s first four-year aesculapian schoolhouse connected nan Brooklyn land, on pinch an accompanying investigation and exertion field that aimed to make Charlotte a halfway for aesculapian innovation.

To make it happen, Atrium said it needed $75 cardinal successful payer money to salary for infrastructure specified arsenic roads, utilities and parking. In return for nan nationalist investment, infirmary leaders made a bid of commitments that they said would assistance up nan full community.

At nan apical of nan database was a committedness to create affordable housing.

The metropolis and region signed off. In July, nan first shape of nan task — now called The Pearl — opened connected 20 acres disconnected South McDowell Street. Two gleaming towers location nan Charlotte field of nan Wake Forest University School of Medicine, a surgical training halfway and a increasing roster of aesculapian exertion companies. 

The $1.5 cardinal invention territory is already being celebrated arsenic a success, fueling caller jobs, investigation opportunities and investments while positioning nan metropolis arsenic a hub for aesculapian innovation. The first aesculapian schoolhouse class started this summer.

So far, however, nan affordable lodging that was promised hasn’t materialized, and it’s not clear erstwhile aliases wherever it mightiness beryllium built.

“They promised america housing, and present it is 2025 and still thing has happened,” said Stowe, who serves connected The Pearl’s organization advisory council. “I’m thinking, ‘Here we spell — we’re getting screwed again.’” 

Housing committedness was cardinal trading point

Atrium’s lodging commitments were many times emphasized successful meetings starring up to nan 2021 metropolis and region votes connected nan hospital’s petition for $75 cardinal successful taxation incentives.

When Atrium Health CEO Gene Woods sounded nan task to nan Charlotte City Council connected Nov. 1, 2021, he emphasized lodging early successful his comments: “We understand that successful processing this site, it’s going to beryllium important to proceed to attraction and beryllium committed to affordable housing, some connected nan tract and besides distant from nan site.” 

A PowerPoint position that nighttime astir nan project laid retired nan hospital’s 2 lodging promises:

• On-site affordable housing: Atrium would group aside 5 percent of apartments successful Phase I of nan aesculapian territory for low-income residents. Since Atrium projected up to 350 units connected site, that meant 18 would beryllium affordable.
• Off-site onshore for much housing: Atrium would donate 14 acres connected North Tryon Street to nan city’s lodging authority, Inlivian, and partner pinch nan agency to build astatine slightest 400 affordable units connected that land.

Some organization members, including Stowe, said astatine nan clip that 5 percent wasn’t capable connected The Pearl site, particularly fixed its history. At a consequent meeting, respective metropolis assembly members asked astir expanding nan percentage, but then-Assistant City Manager Tracy Dodson said it wasn’t possible.

Instead, she said, nan metropolis would get much bang for its subordinate by supporting lodging connected Arium’s North Tryon Street site, wherever improvement costs were lower. Because Inlivian owned an adjacent 14-acre site, nan 2 entities could create a maestro scheme for nan full area, she said.

Four years later, location is nary motion of immoderate lodging — aliases immoderate announced scheme for lodging — astatine either site. And Atrium still owns nan North Tryon Street land, wherever it operates a engaged distribution halfway for aesculapian supplies.

In an emailed statement, Atrium spokesperson Dan Fogleman stressed that nan infirmary strategy is honoring its obligations related to housing: “The arrangements surrounding nan affordable lodging commitments tied to nan TIG [tax-increment grant] are very analyzable and, based connected your statement of questioning, I want to make it clear that Atrium Health has met aliases exceeded what it agreed to do.” 

This PowerPoint descent was presented successful 2021 conscionable earlier The Charlotte City Council voted connected taxation incentives for Atrium Health’s aesculapian invention district.

The first promise: 5 percent of apartments astatine The Pearl

Building affordable lodging is notoriously analyzable and time-consuming, truthful it’s imaginable Atrium and its improvement partners are still putting nan pieces together connected that constituent of nan project. They could reason that Phase I of nan territory is still underway, pinch lodging to come. (The Pearl’s ain website indicates Phase I is complete.)

Fogleman didn’t reply a mobility astir why lodging wasn’t included successful Phase I.

But he did opportunity that Atrium is “working pinch a developer that would see affordable lodging wrong nan territory arsenic portion of its larger project.” 

And it turns retired that, contempt what was presented successful 2021, Atrium isn’t legally bound to see affordable lodging astatine The Pearl.

The Ledger/NC Health News reviewed nan statement betwixt Atrium and nan metropolis and recovered that nan archive does not require low-income lodging to beryllium built arsenic portion of Phase I of The Pearl.

In fact, nan statement includes a caveat that allows Atrium to forgo nan lodging altogether: “It being understood that up to 350 units of specified lodging is contemplated but a determination of including rental lodging wrong nan task has not yet been made.”

If nary apartments are built astatine The Pearl wrong 8 years, nan statement says, past Atrium would request to summation nan number of units built astatine nan North Tryon Street site. 

That helps explicate a consequence from metropolis spokesperson Jack VanderToll. When asked astir nan affordable units that were expected to beryllium portion of Phase I, he responded: “The statement assures that if lodging is built astatine The Pearl, astatine slightest 5 percent will beryllium affordable housing, and it will beryllium portion of nan Phase I development.” (Emphasis added)

In different alteration from what was presented, metropolis leaders were told each of nan affordable units — 5 percent of nan full — would beryllium reserved for residents earning beneath 50 percent of Charlotte’s median income. But nan statement cuts that successful half. It says only 2.5 percent will service those little income households, and nan different 2.5 percent will spell to residents who gain up to 80 percent of nan area median income.

The 2nd promise: Land for 400+ affordable units

Atrium besides pledged successful 2021 to donate a 14-acre tract astatine North Tryon and 32nd streets to Inlivian, wherever a operation of affordable apartments and homes could beryllium built.

City records show Atrium still owns nan land, though it has added a deed regularisation saying immoderate early improvement must beryllium for affordable lodging — arsenic required successful its statement pinch nan city. On a caller afternoon, trucks base nan Atrium logo were pulling successful and retired of a ample storage connected nan site.

When asked astir nan land, Inlivian spokeswoman Cheron Porter told nan Ledger/NC Health News that Atrium was not donating nan spot aft all.

Instead, she said, it was now portion of a projected onshore swap: Atrium wanted Inlivian’s Baxter Street spot adjacent The Pearl for aesculapian offices. In return, it had offered nan North Tryon Street parcel and different spot connected East Morehead Street.

When asked to double cheque her accusation because nan North Tryon parcel was expected to beryllium donated, Porter responded successful an Oct. 3 email: “I tin confirm, this is not a donation.”

This appears to beryllium different lawsuit wherever nan signed ineligible statement betwixt Atrium and nan metropolis doesn’t lucifer nan nationalist promise.

While metropolis officials and nan nationalist were told successful 2021 that Atrium would donate nan full 14-acre parcel to Inlivian, nan statement alternatively says nan developer will “contemplate” contributing nan land. The archive besides says Atrium could contemplate donating only “a portion” of nan onshore alternatively than nan afloat site.

City spokesperson VanderToll did not reply questions astir nan connection successful nan statement aliases whether elected officials were told astir those changes.

Atrium defends lodging efforts

In a letter to elected officials connected Oct. 7 — sent aft nan Ledger/NC Health News started asking questions astir affordable lodging astatine The Pearl — Atrium executive Collin Lane defended nan hospital’s record. He pointed to nan hospital’s $20 cardinal publication to nan city’s Housing Impact Fund. He besides said Atrium was pursuing done connected nan commitments elaborate successful its statement pinch nan city.

Lane’s missive said nan infirmary and Inlivian now person a signed onshore deal, which he characterized arsenic a “negotiated onshore speech of 2 parcels,” not three. He stressed that nan 2 parcels Atrium is transferring to Inlivian are worthy importantly much than nan three-acre Pearl tract nan infirmary is getting successful return.

Lane attributed nan slow advancement connected nan lodging to galore factors, including “multiple iterations of nan deal” and “multiple activity changes astatine Inlivian.” The city, Atrium and Inlivian person besides been moving connected a maestro scheme for nan area, Lane explained.

“Affordable lodging projects return years to complete and, since we are not a developer, we cannot power nan aggregate variables that effect timelines,” Lane wrote.

Although metropolis presentations primitively said Atrium would “partner” pinch Inlivian to create nan North Tryon Street site, nan infirmary now appears to beryllium stepping back:

“As Atrium Health is simply a wellness attraction supplier and not a developer, we’ve entrusted Inlivian to lead nan existent improvement and proceed to cheque successful pinch them regularly connected really we tin support guardant momentum connected this project,” Lane wrote.  

In an emailed consequence to questions, Inlivian’s Porter said nan lodging authority has begun a broad appraisal of nan onshore to find what tin beryllium developed and is collaborating pinch nan metropolis connected a scheme for nan area. She besides said Atrium is “working connected plans to relocate its unit from nan distribution center.”

Council personnel asked for a deadline

At nan Nov. 22, 2021, meeting successful which nan metropolis assembly voted connected nan taxation incentives for The Pearl, then-council personnel Julie Eiselt asked for an assurance that nan affordable lodging astatine North Tryon Street would beryllium developed “within a definite clip frame, possibly a fewer years.”  

In response, Dodson was reassuring: “I said to Atrium astir that today,” she said. “We tin guarantee that 14 acres will spell to affordable housing, and we tin put a clip limit connected erstwhile that could beryllium done. … I deliberation 3 years is realistic erstwhile nan spot changes hands and really is owned by Inlivian.”

When asked whether nan metropolis was holding Atrium accountable to its lodging commitments and that timeline, VanderToll said nan metropolis has been “highly engaged” successful readying for nan area astir nan North Tryon site:

“The Atrium parcel is portion of a larger, analyzable task that includes redevelopment of erstwhile nationalist housing, important organization engagement efforts, rezoning considerations, etc. All of nan partners are successful regular connection arsenic this task moves guardant and each parties are moving together towards nan extremity of delivering affordable lodging connected nan North Tryon site.”  

Residents wanted much lodging successful erstwhile Brooklyn, not less

For immoderate erstwhile Brooklyn residents, Inlivian’s scheme to waste and acquisition its Baxter Street spot adjacent The Pearl to Atrium for aesculapian offices is disappointing, because it removes much onshore that could person been utilized for housing.

Rev. Janet Garner-Mullins, who serves connected The Pearl’s organization advisory council, said keeping nan Inlivian tract connected Baxter Street would person guaranteed astatine slightest immoderate affordable lodging successful nan area that utilized to beryllium Brooklyn.

However, pinch it being fixed up for offices, she said it’s difficult to spot really a important number of affordable apartments for returning residents will ever happen.

“Housing is important connected this tract because of nan historical narration that this spot has to nan Brooklyn neighborhood,” Garner-Mullins said. “To not person lodging present — again — I judge is simply a miscarriage of justice.”

Garner-Mullins said Atrium’s original committedness to designate arsenic affordable only 5 percent of a imaginable 350 units on-site was already inadequate. 

“It’s an insult” that nan infirmary hasn’t built those units yet aliases unveiled a tract scheme for them, she said. “It sends a connection to nan organization that they’re putting profits complete people.”

Commissioners person pressed for updates

Earlier this year, Lane, nan Atrium executive, went earlier nan Mecklenburg County commissioners to connection an update connected really nan infirmary was gathering its commitments. The committee pressed for specifications connected nan on-site lodging that was expected to beryllium portion of The Pearl and connected nan off-site units promised for North Tryon Street.

Atrium distributed a spreadsheet showing that some lodging efforts remained “in nan readying phase.”

Emails obtained by nan Ledger/NC Health News arsenic portion of a nationalist records petition show that commissioners Laura Meier, Leigh Altman and Mark Jerrell followed up complete nan summer, asking for updates connected nan housing. 

In an Aug. 12 consequence to Meier and Jerrell, Deputy County Manager Leslie Johnson wrote that lodging “is portion of Phase II” of nan invention district, adding that it “is presently successful nan creation shape pinch building planned to statesman wrong adjacent 6 months barring nary unexpected delays.”

Her reply suggested a much definitive timeline than Atrium’s Lane, whose missive said only that Atrium is “in talks pinch a developer to see further affordable/workforce lodging abstraction successful The Pearl arsenic portion of their project.”

“How agelong are we going to person to wait?”

While those updates whitethorn person satisfied region leaders, Stowe said she isn’t getting her hopes up.

Stowe said she goes down to The Pearl each fewer weeks, an acquisition that leaves her pinch mixed emotions. While she has fond memories of nan neighborhood, “our roots were destroyed,” she said. “I can’t show my grandkids wherever I grew up.”

Stowe and Garner-Mullins said they admit efforts to grant nan history of Brooklyn astatine The Pearl pinch an interactive stepping depository called “A Purposeful Walk.” It includes panels that show nan communicative of Brooklyn’s churches, schools, businesses and nan group who lived there. Stowe and Garner-Mullins are prominently featured successful nan installation. 

Still, pinch nan deficiency of advancement connected lodging truthful far, they interest The Pearl will go different lawsuit of promises made and not kept.

“My mobility is, really tin we clasp them accountable?” Stowe said. “Just do what you said you were going to do.”

Garner-Mullins added, “I’ve been told by individuals successful authorities that we person to spot them. Well, really agelong are we going to person to wait?” 

This article is portion of a business betwixt The Charlotte Ledger and North Carolina Health News to produce original wellness attraction reporting. You tin support this effort with a tax-deductible donation. 

Republish our articles for free, online aliases successful print, nether a Creative Commons license.