Can An ‘ethical’ Spyware Maker Justify Providing Its Tech To Ice?

Trending 1 week ago

Paragon, an Israeli spyware institution that claims to run arsenic an “ethical” surveillance vendor, faced scrutiny erstwhile earlier this twelvemonth Italy was caught utilizing Paragon’s tools to spy connected nan phones of 2 journalists. Paragon responded by cutting Italy off from its surveillance products, becoming nan first spyware institution to ever publically sanction 1 of its customers aft nan misuse of its products.

Now, Paragon mightiness look a caller ethical dilemma: whether aliases not it will let ICE agents to usage its spyware.

A $2 cardinal one-year contract that Paragon signed successful September 2024 pinch U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) remains nether reappraisal and has not yet taken effect, and Paragon has truthful acold not supplied ICE’s Homeland Security Investigations pinch its spyware tools, nan institution told TechCrunch. 

Since taking agency successful January, nan Trump management has authorized ICE to transportation retired large-scale migration raids crossed nan U.S., starring to nan detention of thousands of migrants — and galore U.S. citizens — successful portion thanks to information stored successful national databases and utilizing technology provided by govtech elephantine Palantir. Considering ICE is poised to get a importantly larger budget pursuing nan passing of Trump’s flagship Big Beautiful Bill Act into law, spyware could service arsenic a powerful surveillance instrumentality successful nan Trump administration’s migration enforcement operations.

With 2 months near earlier nan statement expires, Paragon whitethorn ne'er proviso its spyware to ICE. But until nan statement runs retired connected September 29, nan U.S. authorities could o.k. it astatine immoderate moment, forcing Paragon to make a determination astir nan usage of its devices connected U.S. soil.

Right now, nan institution doesn’t want to talk astir this dilemma astatine all. When asked by TechCrunch, Paragon would not opportunity what it plans to do if nan statement passes review, aliases explain what will hap pinch its narration pinch ICE if nan statement goes forward. 

Contact Us

Do you person much accusation astir Paragon? From a non-work device, you tin interaction Lorenzo Franceschi-Bicchierai securely connected Signal astatine +1 917 257 1382, aliases via Telegram and Keybase @lorenzofb, aliases email. You besides tin interaction TechCrunch via SecureDrop.

Paragon’s statement pinch ICE has been connected region since nan paperwork was signed. Homeland Security issued a near-immediate stop-work bid pinch nan extremity of reviewing whether nan statement complied pinch a Biden-era executive order. The bid restricts U.S. authorities agencies from utilizing commercialized spyware that could (or has been) abused by overseas governments to break quality rights, aliases to target Americans abroad. 

At nan time, a Biden management charismatic told Wired that nan U.S. authorities had “immediately engaged” apical activity astatine Homeland Security, which houses ICE, to find if nan statement met nan requirements of nan executive order.

Nine months on, Paragon’s statement pinch ICE remains successful limbo, and officials successful nan Trump White House did not person an update connected its status.

Trump management spokesperson Abigail Jackson referred TechCrunch’s questions to Homeland Security, and would not comment, erstwhile asked, astir nan Trump administration’s position connected nan Biden-era spyware executive order, which remains successful effect. 

A spokesperson for Homeland Security and ICE did not supply remark erstwhile contacted by TechCrunch.

Spyware companies person historically been reticent to sanction their customers successful immoderate context, often for fearfulness of reputational harm aliases risking lucrative authorities contracts. After WhatsApp revealed earlier this year that astir 90 of its users, including journalists and quality authorities dissidents, had been targeted pinch Paragon’s spyware, nan institution sought to region itself from nan hacks. Paragon’s executive president John Fleming told TechCrunch past that it only sells to “a prime group of world democracies — principally, nan United States and its allies.”

In different words, Paragon wanted nan world to cognize that it would waste to responsible authorities customers, and its consequence to nan Italy ungraded appears to reenforce nan company’s position. 

But successful calling itself an ethical spyware vendor, Paragon has put nan onus connected itself to judge who it deals with. In doing so, nan institution has besides opened nan doorway for others to scrutinize its authorities customers and their morals — whether they are nan Italian authorities aliases ICE. As governments and their leaders alteration complete time, Paragon whitethorn look nan prime of having to re-evaluate who it useful with.

“Given this administration’s grounds of attacks connected quality authorities and civilian nine organizations, we dream that Paragon would reconsider nan agreement,” said Michael De Dora, nan U.S. defense head astatine Access Now, a nonprofit that has worked to expose spyware abuses.

Lorenzo Franceschi-Bicchierai is simply a Senior Writer astatine TechCrunch, wherever he covers hacking, cybersecurity, surveillance, and privacy. You tin interaction Lorenzo securely connected Signal astatine +1 917 257 1382, connected Keybase/Telegram @lorenzofb, aliases via email astatine lorenzo@techcrunch.com.

More